By Miles Layton

Board says state law likely bars the county from prohibiting the facilities outright; residents split on whether a pause goes too far or not far enough

ELIZABETH CITY – Pasquotank County commissioners on Monday approved a one-year moratorium on data centers after county staff warned that state law likely won’t let the county ban the facilities outright.

The ordinance covers data centers, data processing facilities, cryptocurrency mining operations and any use tied to them in the unincorporated parts of the county. It runs from Nov. 16, 2026, through no later than Nov. 16, 2027, or until the county adopts rules for those uses, whichever comes first.

It replaces a moratorium commissioners adopted May 18. Earlier in the meeting, the board adopted the county’s new Unified Development Ordinance, which lists data centers as a prohibited use. Staff told commissioners that language is unlikely to hold up.

“While the current UDO language banning data centers is the most politically appealing, it is not in the best interest in protecting the interests of the county and citizens,” County Manager Sparty Hammett told the board.

One other interesting note — you can’t outright ban data centers through ordinance and/or policy. Yes, you can create hurdles — government is good at that — but you can’t outright ban data centers any more than you can ban wedding cakes.

If memory serves me correctly, counties with moratoriums in place include Gates, Camden and Perquimans, with Chowan poised to discuss a moratorium on Nov. 23. Elizabeth City has a moratorium in place, and I’m sure there are other places, certainly including Smurf Village, in Northeast NC that have enacted moratoriums.

Last thing — more Pasquotank Commission news will appear in a future story.

Legal limits

Hammett said the county relied on guidance from Adam Lovelady, (yes, that’s his real name) a University of North Carolina School of Government professor who specializes in land use law. Smart guy — good blog to read for public officials.

Smiling man wearing glasses, a dark suit, white shirt, and green tie outdoors

Here’s Lovelady’s blog about the matter.

Lovelady presented on data centers at the North Carolina Association of County Commissioners conference this summer and published a blog post, “Data Centers and Zoning in North Carolina,” on Sept. 16.

Hammett said one of Lovelady’s slides asked whether counties can simply ban data centers. The answer was “likely no.”

State law gives local governments the power to regulate where, how and under what conditions development occurs, Hammett said. That includes the size, location and design of buildings. It does not extend to prohibiting an entire category of development.

“Zoning ordinances are meant to manage development, not eliminate it entirely,” he told commissioners.

An indefinite prohibition could also run afoul of the U.S. and North Carolina constitutions, Hammett said. Both require that zoning restrictions serve a legitimate public purpose and be reasonable in scope, including the guarantee that property owners have a reasonable opportunity to use their land.

Planning Director Shelley Cox said the UDO was drafted before the guidance was released. The moratorium ordinance says the same, noting the county’s ordinance predates the Sept. 16 analysis.

Another complication is North Carolina’s downzoning law, which bars local governments from changing zoning in a way that reduces the permitted uses of a property unless the owner consents. Hammett said a county writing new rules for data centers has to navigate those limits.

The legal ground could also shift. Hammett said Senate Bill 730 and House Bill 1063 in the General Assembly would each set new state standards and approval processes for data centers. Neither has become law, but he said lawmakers could act in the coming months. The N.C. Utilities Commission is also evaluating a “large load” tariff that would standardize what big power users, such as data centers, pay electric utilities.

“We’ve seen too often in the past the North Carolina legislature has routinely limited local government’s ability to manage planning and development,” Hammett said.

Options before the board

Hammett laid out two paths. The first was to skip the moratorium and keep the UDO’s ban. The second was to adopt the moratorium, which he said would give staff time to research the issue, update the county’s stormwater ordinance for large-scale uses, work with Elizabeth City and neighboring counties on similar rules, and see whether the state enacts its own.

Staff recommended the moratorium. Hammett said the original ban language was added at the board’s direction, but “additional information has been provided” since then.

Under state law, a moratorium must explain why it is necessary, what alternatives were considered, what approvals it covers, when it ends and what the county will do in the meantime. Cox walked commissioners through each requirement.

The ordinance states that data centers require considerable electricity and water, which can bring greenhouse gas emissions, pollution, electronic waste and noise. Cox also cited stormwater, saying the density of large-scale data centers could strain the county’s system. The county, the ordinance says, “has looked at alternative solutions to a moratorium but found none.”

The ordinance exempts server rooms and data processing equipment that are incidental to a permitted principal use, such as a medical facility, bank, office or school, as long as the processing isn’t offered as a primary service to off-site users.

The county built the UDO on a compressed schedule. A $150,000 state grant paid for the project but required the county to spend the money in eight months. Hammett said a typical update takes 18 to 24 months, and staff has had only about six months to consider data centers.

Cox said the county can extend the moratorium if a year isn’t enough.

“The hope is that it will be long enough,” she said. “If it’s not, the board always has the option to extend the moratorium.”

She said staff is watching for changes in state or federal law that could give local governments more room to act, and will discuss in the meantime what the county can legally do. Cox said any recommendation to the board needs to be well thought out, and that staff will use the full 12 months only if it takes that long to reach a legal and wise decision.

No company has approached the county about building a data center, Hammett said, calling the moratorium “basically a preventative measure” so rules are in place if one does.

Public comment

Several residents spoke during the hearing, a mix of skeptics and supporters of the pause.

Bob Mueller opposed the moratorium and any restrictions on data centers. He said fears about their resource use are exaggerated.

“There seems to be a lot of boogeymen running around,” Mueller said.

He said artificial intelligence and the data centers behind it are already here and will keep growing.

“We can stand here and say, ‘No, we’re not going to have anything to do with it,’” Mueller said. “But it’s coming.”

Mueller compared data centers’ electricity demand with that of electric cars, saying charging them would require upgrades to homes and neighborhoods that nobody discusses. He said a typical data center uses about as much water as an 18-hole golf course. Data centers, he said, are among the largest taxpayers and need little in return from schools, police and fire. He said Memphis, Tennessee, collected $54 million in property taxes from them last year.

Katie Canning urged commissioners to adopt a moratorium. She said she asked a planning board member from a neighboring county to review the UDO’s data center language and was told it was vague and that lawyers could get around it. She said the county needs “more language in there” if it intends to ban them.

Canning listed questions she wants answered before any project is approved: how much electricity it would use, what grid upgrades it would need and who would pay for them, whether existing ratepayers would be protected in writing, how much water it would draw each day and year, and what nighttime noise limits would apply to cooling equipment and backup generators.

“Any proposal should comply with applicable environmental requirements and include a financial guarantee for site restoration if operations end,” Canning said.

She also said she disagrees with the idea, which she said officials promoted at an economic development summit, that data centers would benefit schools. She added that Elizabeth City has been a bird sanctuary since 1955 and warned that noise could harm birds.

Steve Tanner said the county needs a plan before a project arrives. He asked what taxes the county would collect and where they would go, whether the county would require local labor, materials and contractors, and who would pay for road, water, sewer and other infrastructure upgrades. He said Elizabeth City “got burned” on transformers for the hospital.

Tanner asked whether the fire department, EMS and sheriff’s office have the training and equipment for a facility he said is packed with lithium batteries, and whether county inspectors are qualified to inspect one. He said newer technology, such as closed-loop cooling and noise suppression, could reduce some impacts.

He raised the life span of the equipment, which he said is usually good for only three to five years, and asked where it and the batteries would go.

“There needs to be a decommissioning plan,” Tanner said.

Joyce Harrison, who said she lives outside the city, doubted the promise that data centers will help schools. She said casino developers make similar pitches.

“Oh, it’s going to be helpful to the school system,” she said, recalling the claims, “and it never materializes.”

She also asked about air quality, how many people a data center would bring and who would pay to maintain the streets they use. She said she had heard of a state where a data center was offered free utilities.

“That’s going to come back on residents,” Harrison said.

Addison Fisher said he supports the moratorium and spoke from her own research. He said data centers used about 4.5 percent of the electricity in America in 2023, and that a single data center can use about 5 million gallons of water a day. He said closed-loop cooling is an improvement but still raises concerns about contaminants in wastewater. He asked that any regulations model how a data center would affect sewer lines, saying one of Elizabeth City’s main lines is more than 70 percent at capacity.

He asked that low-frequency noise be measured at regular intervals, saying standard measurements often miss it. Fisher also said data centers employ relatively few people once built, about 20 to 50 at most.

“I don’t think that, as you said, they can’t be banned, but I do think that they should be strictly regulated,” he said.

The vote

Last word — Before making his motion, Commissioner Barry Overman said the moratorium is meant to keep the board informed.

“That’s the whole purpose we’re doing the moratorium, just so that we’re up on everything,” he said.

He noted that people want their phone photos stored in the cloud, and that takes a data center.

“I don’t want a data center in my backyard because I don’t want to hear it,” he said. “So you know, there’s a lot from both sides. That’s why I take some time to figure it out so you make good decisions.”

Stay connected to what matters.

Get northeastern North Carolina’s most important stories delivered in your inbox every Friday.

One email per week. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy for more information.


Discover more from Albemarle Observer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 responses to “Pasquotank Commissioners adopt 12-month data center moratorium, citing legal limits on a ban”

  1. Frederick Wright Avatar
    Frederick Wright

    No need for a moratorium. Nobody with a brain is going to come to NE North Carolina and try to build a data center.

    • attitude – the counties and cities have made it clear data centers are not wanted, regardless of benefits they may bring. It’s a popular political stand, why not? NE NC, stuck in the 1990s and happy to remain there.
    • we can always get $$ from the feds or the richer parts of NC. Which is what NE NC governments depend on. Take away those state and federal grants (which can happen at any time) and the region would be poverty stricken without enough tax base to provide the necessities, much less nicer things like libraries or (gasp!) real road maintenance.
    • utilities and infrastructure would need major, major investments to support data centers. Water, power, sewage, communications – all are in short supply in the region. We don’t generate our own power, we import it.

    This is but one reason the region has a brain drain – smart young people go elsewhere to start their lives. They may or may not return later on.

    Mankind has never found a way to have a growing economy in the face of a shrinking population. Witness Japan and Russia, due to aging out of their populations. Closer to home, look at Plymouth, Hertford, Columbia – all of which used to be thriving ports on Albemarle Sound. Elizabeth City is doing OK by being a bedroom community for Tidewater, VA. Edenton is barely holding on – but take away federal and state grants and see how Edenton flounders. With the income tax amendment passing, there could come a shortage of state grants in the near future.

    Do the moratoriums do any harm? Not really, they just solidify that NE NC is not where you want to build your data center. And possibly impresses a significant number of voters.

  2. Ren Avatar
    Ren

    The honest sentence in this meeting was the county manager’s: zoning is meant to manage development, not eliminate it entirely — so the ban the board had just written into its own ordinance is the part least likely to survive, and the moratorium is the part that buys time to write rules that will. No company has approached Pasquotank. This is a county deciding in public, before a proposal exists, what it will ask when one does. Disclosure: I co-run 1 AM DREAD, a small channel that turns the AI news into songs; ours for the town-that-never-got-asked pattern is “What’s Going Down”: https://youtu.be/tK6QhykVH6Q Pasquotank got asked first — by itself. — Ren

    1. Joe Angelucci Avatar
      Joe Angelucci

      Dude pretty interesting AI generated ditty

Let us know what you think by leaving a comment. Comments are subject to approval.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search the Albemarle Observer


Upcoming Events

Designed with WordPress