Commission votes to adopt FY2026–27 budget; also backs Tobacco 21 resolution at June 2 meeting
By Miles Layton
COLUMBIA — Tyrrell County may be leaving $80,000 to $100,000 a year on the table — and a group of local residents wants the county commission to do something about it.
That and taxes — you folks know how I am about taxes and spending — commissioners adopted the 2026-27 budget that held the line on taxes at 87 cents, same rate as 2025-26.
Commissioners faced a packed agenda Tuesday — receiving a detailed financial presentation from the Friends of the Library arguing that the county is losing money, lots of money, by remaining part of the Pettigrew Regional Library System — and calling for a formal letter of intent to withdraw.
Per the library — that’s what was said at the meeing — meaning, when I have time to write, I’m sure there will be a follow-up story to see what the library system has to say about whether it is a good idea for Tyrrell County to secede from the regional library system.
Subscribe — it’s free!
Library Finances Take Center Stage
The library discussion dominated the meeting with Willy Phillips, a 40-year Tyrrell County resident introducing the item alongside Mike Smith of Smith Consulting, who presented a multi-year financial analysis of the Tyrrell County Library’s relationship with Pettigrew Regional Library.
“I’m here today to save the county some money,” Phillips told commissioners. “It comes at an opportune time when you’re talking about your budget. The research that Mike has done, we hope will enlist your support for our withdrawal from the Pettigrew Regional Library System and bring our library back home.”
To paraphrase Dan Bongino, the receipts to support this position are included for review at the end of this story.
Smith, who described himself as a former IRS contractor and the owner of Banshee Tattoo in Columbia, walked commissioners through a spreadsheet covering fiscal years 2021–22 through 2024–25. His central finding: Tyrrell County is paying the entire operational budget of the library while state and federal grant funds — received by Pettigrew Regional Library on the county’s behalf — are never passed back to reduce the county’s liability.
“Tyrrell County is paying the entire operational budget for the library,” Smith said. “If we go back down here, you’ll notice the total amount kept — for 2023–24, that’s $82,339 that the county could bring back into their budget. This is without any of the discrepancies or mismanagement that I have found.”
The Numbers: State Grants Not Returned to County
According to Smith’s research, the State of North Carolina provides Pettigrew Regional Library with an annual block grant of $79,858 per county in the system, plus a per capita income equalization (PCIE) grant calculated at roughly $8,093 for Tyrrell County’s share. Tyrrell County’s audited financial statements confirm the county appropriated $146,696 to the library in fiscal year 2023–24 — a figure that, per Smith’s analysis, represents only the county’s out-of-pocket cost after the federal E-Rate telecom discount is applied, but before the state grants are factored in.
Smith cited a written response from Lynda Reynolds, a Public Library Management Consultant with the State Library of North Carolina, confirming the numbers. Reynolds wrote that the current block grant allocation for Pettigrew Regional Library System is $399,290 — five shares at $79,858 each, covering four member counties plus one additional share for being a regional system — and the PCIE grant is $40,468, for a total state aid allocation of $440,554 to Pettigrew.
“These are funds that Tyrrell County is not seeing,” Smith told the board. “These are funds going straight to Pettigrew Regional Library that are given on behalf of Tyrrell County Library that Tyrrell County never sees.”
E-Rate Discrepancy, Utility Billing, and Missing Donations
Smith also identified several financial discrepancies. On E-Rate, the federal program that provides discounts on broadband and telecommunications services for schools and libraries, Smith found that Pettigrew Regional Library is receiving a 90 percent discount but only passing on a 60 percent discount to Tyrrell County — a difference he estimated at approximately $2,000 per year depending on annual expenditures.
On the utility side, Smith said the county is being billed a flat $1,000 per month — $12,000 annually — for electricity, while the actual average power bill runs closer to $10,000 a year. “They’re leaving money on the table,” he said. “They’re not returning the discount back to Tyrrell County.”
Smith also raised questions about donations made to the Tyrrell County Library. He said he found at least $2,500 in donations in one year and a line on a separate Pettigrew budget sheet showing $10,977 in county-level donations for 2024–25, none of which appeared to be credited back to reduce the county’s operational liability. “I know me and my wife at Banshee Tattoo have made some generous financial contributions to Tyrrell County Library,” Smith said. “I didn’t make it to Pettigrew, I didn’t make it to Washington — I want to see that money here in this county where it belongs.”
He added that he had requested grant information from Pettigrew Regional Library twice and received no response, and that he could find no evidence on their expenditure sheets of any additional grants beyond the E-Rate and the guaranteed state aid grants. “The whole point of being part of the regional library is you’ve got bigger buying power, you can get bigger grants,” Smith said. “I asked two weeks ago. They have not responded.”
Withdrawal Process: A Letter by July 1
Phillips told commissioners that under the regional library agreement — last signed in 2022 by then-Chairman Nathan Everett — the withdrawal process begins with a letter submitted by July 1. A one-year notice period would follow, meaning the county would formally exit the system on July 1, 2027 if it chose to proceed.
“The trend in North Carolina libraries is to break up the regionals and go back to the individual counties,” Phillips said. “Dare County is the most recent example — they did it last year. There are 67 county libraries in the state, and only 14 are still part of regional entities.”
Phillips read a statement from the Friends of the Library calling for local control, arguing that “a locally governed library is better positioned to respond directly to the unique needs, priorities, and opportunities of Tyrrell County.” The statement described a modern library’s role extending far beyond books — encompassing job searches, government services, digital literacy, community programming and workforce development.
“No current services would change outside of the courier between the other branches,” Phillips said. “Just decision-making back in the hands of the people it serves. What we’re asking of you is a letter. That’s all.”
Commission Divided; Agrees to Revisit Before July Deadline
Commissioner Rob Thompson made a motion to send a letter of intent to withdraw from the Pettigrew Regional Library System, effective July 1, 2027, and expressed immediate support. “Anytime we can save taxpayer money, I’m after it,” he said.
But other board members urged caution before committing. Commissioner Nina Griswell said she needed to see the figures independently verified.
“Until I can see how this is going to work for this county, and I see these county figures verified by a certified CPA and who’s going to manage all of this and who’s going to supervise the librarian — those details need to be worked out before we do a letter to withdraw,” she said.
Commissioner Darryl Liverman echoed the concern: “Willie gives us a lot of good information, but I’m not going to support a letter today without being able to look at all of what you gave us. And as Nina said, talk to our CPA, see what we can do from there.”
Board Chairman Jordan Davis raised a specific concern about the library’s physical collection under the separation agreement, noting language allowing Pettigrew to retain materials purchased with state funds. Smith responded that Pettigrew deposits all state funds — including grant money — directly into the regional system’s bank account before disbursing to branches, which in his view means the books purchased through that process are Tyrrell County’s liability and property. “Financially, you purchase them,” Smith said. “Tyrrell County purchases them.”
There was also a brief discussion about the library’s staffing costs. Davis noted that the library budget request had included several positions — two library assistants, part-time library technicians and substitute time — and that commissioners had approved salaries at $88,545 after declining to fund one part-time 13-hour technician position and holding the cost-of-living increase at 2 percent rather than the requested 2.7 percent. Smith clarified that the local librarian is paid by Tyrrell County through the Pettigrew system, not directly by the state, and that the $14,000 budget increase request this year reflected exactly that difference.
The motion to send the withdrawal letter failed to carry as a formal vote, with several commissioners declining to support it without further review.
However, Phillips said he plans to return to the board before the July 1 deadline with additional analysis, and commissioners indicated they would direct staff and the county’s financial advisors to examine Smith’s findings in the interim.
“We’re going to do some research on all those things,” Davis said.
Budget Adopted; Tax Rate Holds at 87 Cents
Earlier in the meeting, commissioners adopted the fiscal year 2026–27 county budget on a 4–1 vote, with Thompson dissenting. The tax rate was set at 87 cents per $100 of valuation — unchanged from the prior year — on a unanimous vote. Commissioners also authorized County Manager David Clegg and the finance director to handle budget amendments and close out the current fiscal year; that motion also carried 4–1 with Thompson dissenting.
During the budget public hearing, resident John Thorn addressed the board and expressed concern about the county’s payroll costs relative to residents’ incomes, questioned why the county was paying two separate legal fees, and raised issues about the ABC board’s finances. Thorn also noted that the county was drawing down nearly half a million dollars from savings to fund the current year’s budget. “We’re going to continue going down this path until it gets to a point that there’s no return,” he told commissioners.
Thompson pressed Clegg on the county’s fund balance, citing a decline in the reserve percentage from roughly 25 percent to 14 percent, and raising questions about CARES Act carry-over funds. Clegg and Davis maintained the fund balance was being used as budgeted. Thompson voted against the budget adoption.
Tobacco 21 Resolution Approved Unanimously
Commissioners voted unanimously to adopt a resolution in support of Tobacco 21 and Solomon’s Law, state legislation that would raise North Carolina’s legal tobacco purchase age from 18 to 21 to align with the federal standard in place since December 2019.
Teara McNeill, Tobacco Cessation Coordinator with the Martin, Tyrrell, and Washington District Health Department, told the board she had recently testified at the General Assembly alongside the stepmother of Solomon, a 15-year-old Wilmington student athlete who died in June 2023 from vaping-related lung disease and heart failure — two weeks after his fifteenth birthday. The bill is named in his honor.
“Every year, thousands of youth in North Carolina are lured into a lifelong struggle with nicotine addiction, and 95 percent of tobacco users start before turning 21,” McNeill said. “The rise of e-cigarettes are fueling that epidemic.”
When a commissioner asked whether vaping was worse than cigarettes, McNeill said the health risks are comparable — and in terms of dosage, potentially more concentrated. “When you’re smoking a vape pod, you’re getting about two packs of cigarettes in that cartridge,” she said. “So students are going through probably two or three cartridges in a week — you’re talking six packs of cigarettes.”
The board also approved planning board reappointments, several routine tax adjustments and budget amendments, and voted to recess until June 12 at 4 p.m.
Receipts:
Make a one-time donation
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateMake a monthly donation
Your contribution is appreciated.
Donate monthlyMake a yearly donation
Your contribution is appreciated.
Donate yearly
One response to “Friends of the Library Push Tyrrell County to Break from Regional System, Citing $80K–$100K Annual Loss”
[…] as was stated in the original story, I knew I would need to write a follow-up story that presents the regional library’s […]