By Miles Layton
ELIZABETH CITY – The Pasquotank County Board of Commissioners approved a request Monday night to rezone 33.43 acres off Mill Pond Road for a residential subdivision. The decision went against the recommendations of county planning staff and the Planning Board.
The land is currently zoned A-1 agricultural. Under the new zoning, the property could hold up to 30 homes on lots of at least 43,000 square feet, a requirement because the site has no central sewer and would rely on septic systems. The property is outside the 100-year flood zone.
Approved 5-1, the rezoning allows developer Linwood Williams to extend his Oak Ridge subdivision in Newland Township. Commissioner Sean Lavin cast the lone vote against the rezoning. Commissioner Barry Overman provided insight into why he supported the zoning change — their thoughts are toward the end of the story.
Commissioners’ boardroom at the Pasquotank County Courthouse was packed well before the hearing began, with people standing in the hallway outside. It was so crowded with people that I could smell one guy’s bad breath – folks were sitting on the floor too.
Everyone made good points – more of that will appear in a separate story, along with other items of interest from the 2-hour+ meeting: data center moratorium, UDO and Commissioners Barry Overman and Charles Jordan saying goodbye.
Staff report against
County Planning Director Shelley Cox told commissioners that staff and the Planning Board had both recommended denial. The Planning Board voted 5-1 that the rezoning was not reasonable and not in the public interest.
Cox said the 2023 Pasquotank County Land Use Plan classifies the site as agricultural and rural, and the request is inconsistent with that designation. She pointed to plan goals that call for preserving the quiet rural agricultural character of the county, directing growth toward Elizabeth City and interchange areas, and steering development away from sensitive environmental areas.
She also noted that the site borders Oak Ridge, which was rezoned residential in 2013, and that the plan acknowledges growth spilling over from Hampton Roads and continued demand for housing.
Cox explained that a planning board finding of inconsistency does not bar commissioners from approving a rezoning. If the board approves a request that conflicts with the plan, she said, the approval also amends the county’s future land use map for that property.
The developer’s case
Williams, a general contractor who brought his son Kevin to the podium, said the project would finish what he started 40 years ago with Oak Ridge One and Two. About 80 homes are there now, he said.
“We’ll only build approximately four houses per year,” Williams said, adding that such a pace would not strain schools or the community. He said the land has been in his family for 150 years, and he uses local builders, subcontractors and suppliers.
“We see it as providing an opportunity for folks to have a part of the American dream,” he said.
Jon Van Dalsum, a subcontractor who has worked with Williams for 43 years, said he had gone back to homes 30 and 35 years after they were built and found no settling problems. He said he pulled his records for the past 26 years and found Williams averaged 4.25 homes a year.
“You can’t ask for any more controls than a man who builds four homes a year,” Van Dalsum said.
Pastor Daniel Spence, a longtime resident from that neck of the woods, said neighbors in the area back Williams. He disputed the argument that new homes would worsen traffic.
“The biggest traffic comes from the farm trucks,” Spence said, citing tractor-trailers hauling feed and grain.
Keith Brown, a retired veteran, said he bought homes from Williams after others fell short of what he wanted. “I got a house like I wanted,” he said.
Keith Rivers, president of the Pasquotank County branch of the NAACP, urged commissioners to approve the request. Rivers said school funding at the local level is driven by property taxes, and growth is what draws businesses. Denying a landowner the right to build because of an agricultural designation, he said, would set a precedent that would come up again. He also said Williams was among the first Black developers to build a community in the area.
Opponents cite plan, flooding, schools
Ben Barnhill, an outspoken opponent against turning the kind of unrestricted growth that transforms country fields into suburbs, argued the request would let a major subdivision into an area the plan designates for farms at low density.
“Zoning is supposed to follow that. Not rewrite it one project at a time,” Barnhill said. “State law requires consistency. That’s the standard, not a suggestion.”
He warned that approval would invite larger developers to point to the decision, and he cited a 1,700-unit project planned in Camden.
Carolee Fleming, who farms on Millpond Road with her husband and works in real estate, noted that the parcel has no county water or sewer. She cited a Newland Township resilience study the county commissioned through the state’s Resilient Coastal Communities Program, which she said describes the township as frequently flooded and lists a watershed drainage model as a priority the county has not yet built.
“Why are property owners and septic systems in areas the study calls frequently flooded before the drainage work is done?” she asked. She also said the county was set to hold a hearing later that night on a new unified development ordinance, and she urged the board to wait and apply the new rules.
Her husband, Brandon Fleming, a small beef producer, said rezoning farmland to residential would likely force him to look at moving so he could expand his operation.
Dale Hoak, a Navy veteran whose family runs a horse-boarding business next to the property, said part of the site comes within about 30 feet of his pastures.
“I’m not opposed to growth or development or private property,” Hoak said. He said he objected to development that disregards established land use plans and threatens existing agricultural businesses. Once new residents move in, he said, “it just becomes a matter of time before the agricultural activities become the nuisance and not the norm.”
Hoak also said Mill Pond Road is a dirt road that he and his neighbors maintain at their own expense with no help from the county. He said construction could remove culverts and push water across it.
Katie Canning, who lives in the city and recently ran as a write-in candidate for school board, asked commissioners to table or deny the request. She asked where the drainage and traffic studies were. She said teachers had told her they were drained by overcrowding.
Susan Ayers, who moved to Mill Pond Road from Virginia Beach four years ago, said traffic is already a challenge. “I don’t want to see it turned into a free for all,” Ayers said. She said her granddaughter could not ride the school bus to high school because there was no room.
Another resident, who gave her name as Bev Barnill, said her grandson’s school was already at capacity. “Kids fall through the cracks,” she said, and she asked the board to slow down. Carl Witten said he had spoken with several Newland residents, some who would be directly affected, and all were against it.
Commissioners weigh in
Commissioner Overman, who made the motion to approve, began by saying he did not rule by emotion. He said he was troubled by the way the debate had played out online.
“Facebook has yet won again,” Overman said. “Social media used to bring us together, now it seems to divide us.”
Overman said he had reviewed the past decade and found that only about 0.062 percent of county land had been rezoned. He noted that he was on the board the last two times it approved such rezonings, both in the Weeksville area. Both requests, he said, were turned down by the Planning Board for not matching the land use plan, and commissioners went against that advice.
He said the plan works well but doesn’t account for the permits the county issues almost weekly to build houses on agricultural land, which don’t come before the board because they aren’t subdivisions. Overman said he built his own house on his grandfather’s farm.
“We have the opportunity to look at it holistically and make a decision: Is this impact going to be minimal, or is it not?” he said. Overman said Williams’ pace of about four houses a year was “very minor when it comes to impact.”
The motion passed with Lavin opposed.
In an exclusive interview with the Albemarle Observer after the meeting, Lavin said his vote came down to the land use plan, which the county spent more than $100,000 drafting.
“It’s inconsistent with what we’ve been saying we were doing,” Lavin said.
Lavin said he knows Williams personally and thinks highly of him. “Nothing against the developer,” he said. “I think he does a lot for the community. He’s well respected.” But he said he looked at the merits of the rezoning, and he noted that the land was bought with the intent to rezone it.
Lavin cited a study of residential development in Johnston County – the study is posted at the end of the story – that he said found such projects cost counties more in services than they generate in taxes. By his recollection, the study put the loss at roughly 43 cents for every dollar of tax revenue. He called residential growth the worst type of development for a county, citing the strain on power and water infrastructure, schools, emergency services and other county services.
He estimated the project could cost the county roughly $250,000 a year once the homes are built. He based that on homes valued at about $300,000 each, which he said would leave the county a deficit of a few thousand dollars per house.
“On the surface, it looks like a good development,” he said. “When you start scratching it and realizing that it’s in an overpopulated area, traffic congestion is an issue, flooding is an issue.”
Lavin said the math is why the county should look more closely at commercial and industrial projects. He said farmland costs the county roughly 80 cents in services for every dollar it brings in, mostly because the land’s value is low, while commercial development costs closer to 40 cents.
“Eventually, you can understand how we get to too many houses,” Lavin said. “We can’t support them.”
Johnston County Study







Let us know what you think by leaving a comment. Comments are subject to approval.