BY MILES LAYTON
PLYMOUTH — During a lengthy discussion at Monday night’s Plymouth Town Council meeting, members wrestled with how to fairly compensate Police Chief Louis Banks, who is currently performing dual roles as chief and patrol officer due to chronic understaffing in the department.
Chief Banks, a salaried employee classified as “exempt” under federal labor laws, is not entitled to overtime pay. Despite this, he routinely works 12-hour shifts on patrol in addition to his administrative duties — a workload council members said is unsustainable and unjustly uncompensated. Banks’ annual salary is $80,050 according to Town Hall.
Banks is an experienced law officer with prior service at “duty stations” including the Washington County Sheriff’s Office, Scotland Neck PD, Williamston PD and even Hertford PD. Banks joined Plymouth PD as chief detective in 2022, then became chief about a year ago in July of 2024.
Let’s talk workload — Plymouth PD has six vacancies — 60 percent of the department.
Presently, PPD has only four officers — Chief, Captain, and two Detectives — at full staff, the PPD would employee 10 people. Wow! On that note, PPD is looking for a few good officers — click this link.

Before moving onto with this story — here is an article about proposed changes to Plymouth’s water and sewer rates.
Back to Banks — Council members expressed sympathy and frustration as they weighed legal limitations against fiscal realities.
Councilwoman Crystal Davis initiated much of the discussion, asking pointed questions about how mental health and drug-related crises are handled by the short-staffed department, and whether Chief Banks is still personally responding to calls.

Davis deserves credit for steering council to the amount of hours that Banks has been working in order to start a discussion about how and why to compensate him.
“Yes, ma’am,” Banks replied. “Because of us being shorthanded, I work a patrol spot just like the other officers. I don’t get to work Monday through Friday, eight to five. I fill in wherever needed, with no compensation.”
Town Manager Joanne Floyd explained that exempt employees — such as the chief, town clerk, and herself — are not eligible for overtime. “The only way to compensate is through salary increases or bonuses,” she said, noting that the town had already consulted with attorneys and the UNC School of Government on the matter.
The conversation highlighted a dilemma: how to recognize extraordinary service by the chief without creating a precedent that could open the town up to future claims or liabilities.
Floyd acknowledged the delicate balance. “You don’t want to put Chief Banks or the town in a difficult legal position. But we’re still researching every possible way,” she said.
Council members floated several potential solutions, including a temporary salary increase, a structured bonus, or compensatory time. Davis suggested looking into a one-time bonus based on hours already worked that could be categorized separately from base pay.
“I’m just saying hypothetically — say he’s worked 400 extra hours. Instead of an ongoing pay increase, couldn’t we take those hours and convert them into a bonus?” Davis asked.
Floyd said that was feasible. “You can do a bonus. The town has the authority. There would be tax implications, but it’s a possible option.”
Still, other council members warned of unintended consequences. “What about the other exempt employees? What happens if we do this for one and not for the others?” one asked. Floyd echoed that concern, pointing out that such a move could lead to expectations among other department heads, even if they aren’t working as many hours.
Yet several council members agreed that the police chief’s situation is unique. “He’s been working like this for a long time. Other departments may be exempt too, but they’re not shortstaffed like this,” one member said. “This is not about setting a blanket policy — this is about responding to extraordinary service under difficult conditions.”
The council also discussed how the town’s strained finances might impact any raise or bonus. “If we increase salaries to compensate, where does that put us? Can we draw from fund balance? What about long-term sustainability?” members asked.
Floyd noted that similar adjustments have been made before. When she took on multiple roles several years ago — including manager, finance officer, and town clerk — she received an increase of $5,000 to $10,000 to reflect the expanded responsibilities.
As the discussion went on, some members suggested moving the conversation into a closed session, citing the need to respect the personnel nature of the matter.
By meeting’s end, the council agreed to revisit the topic in closed session later that evening, with the goal of finding a lawful and fair solution that recognizes Chief Banks’ dedication — without opening the town up to legal or financial risk.
The chief, who was present for the meeting, remained quiet for much of the conversation, but his commitment to serving the town was evident throughout.
“We know the hours you’re working,” one council member said. “We want to do right by you.”
Subscribe/Donate
If you want to subscribe — FREE — check out our website at https://albemarleobserver.news/
If you want to subscribe – you can enter your email address at the website or send it to us at albemarle.observer@gmail.com and we will gladly add you to our growing subscriber list.
You can also donate by going to the Donations page by clicking here or send us a check at Albemarle Observer, C/O Miles Layton, 205 E. Church St. Apt. A, Edenton, NC 27932.
