BY MILES LAYTON
PLYMOUTH — A proposed overhaul of Plymouth’s water and sewer rate structure could reduce monthly bills for many residential customers while ensuring the town’s utilities are financially sustainable for years to come, according to a presentation delivered Monday night by Will Larsen of The Wooten Company. That said, commercial customers may see rates increase.
Speaking to the Plymouth Town Council, Larsen outlined findings from a comprehensive rate study and capital improvement plan developed as part of the closeout of a 2021 Wastewater Asset Inventory and Assessment (AIA) grant. That multi-year project examined the condition of the town’s infrastructure and laid the groundwork for proposed changes to rates, revenue models, and long-term investments.
Larsen said the goal of the study was threefold: to ensure the water and sewer system generates enough revenue to cover operational expenses, to fund capital improvements, and to create a rate structure that is fair and manageable for all customer classes—residential, commercial, industrial, and institutional.
“This is a tool for the town,” Larsen said. “Any action requires your approval. But the goal is to put Plymouth on a path to financial sustainability in its utility operations.”
$5 Million in Infrastructure Needs
Plymouth’s water and sewer systems are facing more than $5 million in anticipated capital needs over the next five years, Larsen said. That includes improvements to aging pipes, treatment facilities, and other infrastructure essential to service delivery.
Debt service for those capital projects is estimated to reach over $300,000 annually. When combined with ongoing operational costs—such as chemicals, electricity, maintenance, and personnel—Larsen projected that Plymouth would need about $2.81 million annually to operate its utilities sustainably by year five.
Currently, the town is only projected to generate $2.52 million in annual revenue from its water and sewer funds, creating a shortfall that could otherwise require general fund subsidies. Larsen said the rate study was designed to close that gap while minimizing the impact on residents.
Fixed vs. Variable Costs
The analysis broke down Plymouth’s utility budget into fixed and variable costs. Fixed costs—such as administration, debt service, and capital expenses—are those that don’t change with customer usage and account for approximately $2.5 million annually. Variable costs, on the other hand, depend on water consumption and sewer flow, covering things like treatment and pumping expenses.
“Once we’ve identified those cost drivers, we can match them to different types of rate structures,” Larsen explained. “The idea is to create a more transparent and predictable billing system.”
Why Change the Rate Structure?
Currently, Plymouth uses an “increasing block rate” system. Residential water customers pay a $30 minimum charge for up to 2,000 gallons, $9 per 1,000 gallons between 2,000 and 10,000 gallons, and $11 per 1,000 gallons beyond that. Sewer customers pay a similar rate, starting at a $32 base charge.
The Wooten Company recommended transitioning to a uniform rate structure, in which customers pay the same rate per 1,000 gallons regardless of usage. Funding agencies such as the North Carolina Division of Water Infrastructure favor uniform structures for their simplicity and budget predictability.
“Uniform rates make it easier to explain bills to customers and to forecast revenues,” Larsen said. “Yes, it’s less conservative from a conservation standpoint, but the trade-off is a more stable financial model.”
Residential Savings, Commercial Impact
Under the proposed structure, the minimum monthly charge for residential water customers would drop significantly—from $30 to $13.45. A uniform per-gallon charge of $4.50 per 1,000 gallons would apply beyond the base level.
That means a residential customer who uses 5,000 gallons per month could see their bill decrease from roughly $57 to around $36, Larsen said.
Sewer rates would follow a similar path. Residential customers would pay a $15.16 base rate (down from $32) with a per-thousand-gallon charge of slightly more than $3.
Larsen said the decrease for residential customers would be offset by higher charges for commercial users, who tend to have larger impacts on the system.
Commercial water customers would see a new minimum monthly bill of $16.14, with a corresponding volumetric rate. Commercial sewer rates would start at $18.60. Customers located outside the town limits—who currently pay the same base rate as in-town users—would see their minimums double, reflecting the increased cost of delivering service.
“For example, an outside commercial water customer would see a base charge of $32.28,” Larsen explained. “That reflects both service delivery costs and the greater infrastructure strain.”
Options for Implementation
Two implementation strategies were offered to the council: a single-step adjustment or a phased transition over three steps within five years.
The single-step option would adopt the new rates immediately and hold them steady through the study’s five-year horizon. The phased option would gradually transition customers to the new structure, easing any sudden financial impacts on commercial users.
Larsen said both options would lead to the same ultimate financial outcome, but the phased approach could help smooth the political and customer service implications of a significant rate restructuring.
Customer Classes and Equity
Plymouth has approximately 1,279 water customers and 1,284 sewer customers, divided among residential and commercial users and categorized further into inside and outside town limits. Larsen emphasized that equity was a core principle of the proposed model.
“Industrial users impact infrastructure differently than residential customers,” he said. “We recommend separating rate classes and billing them accordingly to reflect the true cost of service.”
The report also outlined and rejected two other rate models: seasonal rates, typically used in tourism-heavy areas, and decreasing block rates, which can be confusing for customers and unpredictable in revenue forecasting.
“Those models didn’t make sense for Plymouth,” Larsen said. “Uniform rates are the best fit.”
What’s Next?
No vote was taken Monday night. Larsen reminded council members that his presentation was part of the final step required to close out the AIA grant and that formal adoption of any new rate structure would require a future vote.
“We recommend the council review the full report when it is received and consider taking action at a later meeting,” he said. A sealed and final copy of the rate study will be submitted to the Division of Water Infrastructure along with all closeout documentation.
Broader Implications
The proposed changes come at a time when small towns across North Carolina are grappling with aging utility infrastructure and pressure from state agencies to become more financially self-sustaining. Plymouth’s proactive approach, bolstered by data and expert analysis, aims to balance affordability with long-term responsibility.
“This isn’t just about billing,” Larsen said. “It’s about making sure Plymouth can maintain safe, reliable water and sewer services for the next generation without constantly leaning on emergency repairs or general fund bailouts.”
While some residents may welcome lower monthly bills, especially in a town where income levels remain modest, council members will need to weigh the broader effects of shifting costs toward commercial users and enforcing higher rates for out-of-town customers.
For now, the issue remains under discussion. But with infrastructure needs growing and financial gaps looming, the urgency to act will likely accelerate.
Editor’s Note: The full water and sewer rate report is expected to be delivered to town officials in the near future. Public input may be sought once the council begins considering implementation options.

One response to “Understanding Plymouth’s Proposed Utility Rate Structure”
[…] moving onto with this story — here is an article about proposed changes to Plymouth’s water and sewer […]